The Cosmic Intruder: What Is 3I/ATLAS?
Astronomers saw it in July 2025: an object unlike most comets, an interstellar visitor from outside our Solar System. Officially dubbed 3I/ATLAS (also C/2025 N1), it is the third interstellar object confirmed to pass through our cosmic neighborhood.
Right from the start, 3I/ATLAS has been full of surprises: high speed, odd chemical signatures, and evolving appearance. Observatories worldwide have turned their instruments toward it, with James Webb (JWST) among the most powerful.
The “Hostile Color” Claim: Turned Green, Turned Threat?
Recently, reports began circulating that 3I/ATLAS was “turning green” — a “hostile color” in sensational headlines implying alien or threatening activity. But what’s really going on?
The Green Glow
Witnesses to a September 2025 total lunar eclipse took photos that revealed the comet with an emerald glow.
A greenish color is nothing new in the realm of comets. It usually occurs because dicarbon (C₂) or other molecules within a comet's coma release in the green portion of the spectrum when they are excited by the sun.
Though, as yet, spectroscopic analyses of 3I/ATLAS have not found evidence for the presence of dicarbon in quantities that completely account for the green hue.
Other astronomers believe the green might be due to other gases, such as cyanide, also found in trace quantities in the coma of the comet.
So although the green-casting phenomenon is interesting, labelling it "hostile" is rhetorical rather than scientifically based.
The "Turning Color" Observations
Aside from being green, an independent study correlating data from the ATLAS network (ground-based observatories) noted that 3I/ATLAS's color index changed:
Early on (c-band minus o-band), the comet was reddish in color.
Later, that index moved towards more neutral (towards the Sun's color), parallel to the visibility of a dust tail.
The explanation: as outgassing from the comet grows, frozen grains and new material become exposed, changing the way sunlight scatters and appears to color.
This change isn't evidence of hostility — it's one of the things comets do when they're warmed by the Sun.
What James Webb Actually Saw
To cut through the hype, let's examine what the JWST data indicate.
CO₂-Dominated Coma
In August 2025, JWST's NIRSpec instrument observed the gas in the coma of the comet (the thin atmosphere surrounding the nucleus).
The shocking finding: carbon dioxide (CO₂) is the ruling volatile, with a CO₂ : H₂O ratio of roughly 8 : 1 — much more than normal comets. That ratio is 6 standard deviations higher than normal for comets.
Also present: water (H₂O), carbon monoxide (CO), carbonyl sulfide (OCS), water ice, and dust.
The CO₂ outgassing is more intense towards the Sun direction, as expected for solar heating to drive activity.
These results don't indicate hostility — they indicate a comet with an atypical chemical signature.
No Alien Tech Confirmed, Please
A speculative (preprint) report suggested 3I/ATLAS might be a "possibly hostile extraterrestrial technology in disguise."
But most astronomers have rejected that notion as unfounded — labeling it "nonsense" or even "insulting" to serious science.
The JWST observations are not in favor of any artificial structure or activity. Rather, they stress that 3I/ATLAS is a highly CO₂-enriched interstellar visitor, very different from most comets we've explored.
In brief: sensational headlines might alarm, but the evidence thus far does not.
Why It Matters: What 3I/ATLAS Has to Teach Us
Even in the absence of hostility, 3I/ATLAS is a treasure for astronomers. Here's why:
Pristine Interstellar Sample
Since it had formed outside the Solar System, it might
bear chemical and physical signatures regarding other planetary systems.
Unusual Composition
Its CO₂ predominance implies either extreme radiation processing (altering its ice budget) or formation near the CO₂ ice line in its parent system.
Comparative Planetology
By comparing 3I/ATLAS with comets within our own Solar System, researchers are able to cross-check theories for comet formation, volatile retention, and galaxy object diversity.
Transient Window
The comet is whizzing by. Observatories have a limited window—particularly before and after its perihelion (close approach to the Sun). JWST might see it again in December.
Yes, 3I/ATLAS is making headlines. Its chemical composition and behavior are odd. The green color is a thrill. But the assertion that JWST "just caught it turning to a hostile color… and it's terrifying" is hype, not science.
Instead of fear, more appropriate is wonder. It's a
precious privilege to glimpse matter that has traveled across the galaxy and
now travels through our Solar System. The test for astronomers is to continue
looking, continue examining, and continue anchoring stories in evidence.
.jpg)
0 Comments