A New Interstellar Mystery
It was in July 2025 that astronomers spotted something crossing our Solar System on a hyperbolic path: called 3I/ATLAS, it is the third interstellar visitor known to date, after 1I/'Oumuamua (2017) and 2I/Borisov (2019).
What has public and scientific interest is a provocative assertion by Harvard theoretical astrophysicist Avi Loeb and his colleagues: the object is releasing—or consists of—metallic alloys unknown on Earth. Essentially, this would mean a composition or materials science far beyond known natural cosmic objects.
The Claim: Alien Materials?
Loeb's hypothesis is presented in a preprint paper, co-authored with Adam Hibberd and Adam Crowl, entitled "Is the Interstellar Object 3I/ATLAS Alien Technology?"
Therein, the authors present a list of "anomalies" in 3I/ATLAS's trajectory, orientation, and observation data, and suggest (as a working hypothesis) that it may have technological origins. Of the anomalies, the exotic metallic alloy claim is interesting.
Based on Loeb's blog and public post, one of the oddities is the presence of nickel without iron in the witnessed spectrum—an anomaly, as most known metal bodies or metal alloys with nickel contain iron or other materials. The fact that there is no iron, he claims, may suggest an industrially produced alloy, not a natural cosmic mineral blend.
He posits that the composition is analogous to "industrial" alloying processes and mixtures not yet found in nature or on the Earth. This is one of the supporting pillars to his contention that 3I/ATLAS could have at least partially artificial origin.
Supporting Anomalies and Context
Loeb and co-workers enumerate some supporting observations and statistical anomalies to support their suggestion. Some of the more notable ones:
Low tilt compared to ecliptic (retrograde orbit): The orbit of 3I/ATLAS is almost coplanar with the Solar System's ecliptic plane, but in retrograde motion. Authors place the probability of such alignment being coincidental at only 0.2%.
Deficiency of cometary outgassing: In contrast to comets, which usually exhibit spectral traces of volatile gases (such as water vapor, CO, etc.), 3I/ATLAS has no definitive indications of outgassing until now. This is not typical for objects coming in near the Sun.
Close encounters with planets: The object seems to pass fairly close to Venus, Mars, and Jupiter in its path—occurrences the authors assert have a combined chance of only ~0.005% for a random interstellar object.
Timing and orbital dynamics for a "solar Oberth" maneuver: The authors suggest that during perihelion (nearest point to the Sun), 3I/ATLAS could do a "reverse solar Oberth maneuver," a high-thrust approach that would cause it to decelerate and continue to be gravitationally bound to the Sun. This maneuver would be occulted from Earth because during perihelion the Sun would be obscuring the object.
Non-gravitational acceleration: They calculate that an acceleration to the tune of ~5.9 × 10⁻⁵ AU/day² (normalized at 1 AU) toward Jupiter could imply a planned trajectory, not exclusively gravitational dynamics.
Cumulatively, Loeb gives a 30–40% probability that 3I/ATLAS is not fully of natural origin—which is a remarkably high probability considering how speculative the hypothesis still is.
Skepticism and Counterarguments
Most of those in the scientific community are skeptical of these claims. Following are the key counterarguments and issues:
No peer-reviewed verification: The hypothesis and data are still mostly in preprint or blogging format. The extraordinary claim requires robust, reproducible evidence.
Spectral ambiguity: The detection of nickel without iron may be a consequence of observational biases, low signal-to-noise ratios, or blending in spectra. It may not always indicate exotic alloying.
Comet behavior can be occulted: It is conceivable that any outgassing is too weak or obscured by dust or orientation effects, particularly early in observations. Certain outgassing signatures may appear closer to the Sun.
"Strange but plausible" natural explanations are possible: Some believe that strange mineralogy, processing by radiation, or other genesis in exotic star systems can create bizarre combinations of alloys naturally.
Statistical over-interpretation: With only three interstellar objects so far (1I, 2I, and now 3I), it's dangerous to infer probabilities or patterns. What seems anomalous could simply be sampling bias or unique one-off behavior.
No definitive non-gravitational propulsion: While Loeb's team estimates probable non-gravitational accelerations, no clear sign of propulsion (e.g. thrust bursts) has been seen yet.
In a scathing counterargument, a SETI researcher countered that Occam's razor continues to prefer natural explanations, observing that we have numerous instances of peculiar comets, asteroids, and interstellar objects; a single or several peculiar characteristics does not necessarily equate to extraterrestrial technology.
Tom Statler, NASA's small Solar System body lead, stated: "It resembles a comet … it does comet stuff … the proof is definitely leaning toward this object being an all-natural object."
What Observations Are Upcoming, and What Might Conclude (or Refute) the Hypothesis
The coming months contain key data that might resolve—or at least strongly narrow—this controversy:
Finer-resolution imaging and spectra: Spacecraft such as NASA's HiRISE, ESA's observing assets, and ground-based telescopes will attempt to resolve more detail, quantify reflectance spectra, and look for chemical lines.
Ongoing acceleration / trajectory monitoring: If 3I/ATLAS shows velocity or path changes incompatible with gravity, that would make the case for propulsion or active control stronger.
Detection of novel alloy signatures or exotics: If spectral lines appear that correlate to no terrestrial composition known, that would be highly compelling evidence.
Seeing changes at perihelion: Since the object is being heated, if suddenly it shows outgassing or fragmentation, that could tip the scales in favor of a natural explanation.
Close approaches and orbital evolution: As 3I/ATLAS approaches Jupiter and then maybe Earth's neighborhood (although it won't approach very closely), gravitational interactions can reveal design or anomalies.
In fact, Loeb and others have produced testable predictions: for example, that an arrival or encounter window around late November to early December 2025 is feasible.
Why This Matters — If True or False
Whether 3I/ATLAS is artificial or not, the ramifications are extreme:
For science and astronomy: Even a proven anomaly assists in streamlining our models of interstellar objects, materials science under extreme conditions, and chemical reactions throughout galaxies.
For astrobiology and SETI: If strong evidence points toward non-natural origins, it would be one of the strongest empirical arguments for extraterrestrial technology to ever be encountered.
For defense of planets and strategy: If intelligent probes are indeed interstellar travelers, humankind would require protocols, sensors, and policy structures (a point emphasized by Loeb)
For public understanding of space science: Such sensational claims get noticed—and scrutinized. How scientists and the media handle skepticism, confirmation, and public expectation will be important.
Caution: Extraordinary Claims Require Extraordinary Evidence
It is essential to emphasize: currently, the hypothesis that 3I/ATLAS radiates unknown metal alloys on Earth is not established. It is a challenging hypothesis, put forward by one of the leading scientists, but it is still speculative.
The scientific approach requires reproducibility, peer review, and independent confirmation. Until spectra, imaging, and dynamical data decisively indicate one direction or another, the alternative remains available—but not established.
For the time being, 3I/ATLAS is a cosmic enigma—a traveler from another star system, perhaps with secrets regarding material makeup, planetary formation, or even extraterrestrial intelligence. As more information comes in from telescopes and instruments, we might soon know if this is a natural interstellar traveler, or something truly extraordinary.
0 Comments